Vision Capital Management Financial Advisor Portland Oregon

Vision Capital Management has been providing clients financial planning and investment management services since 1999. Visit our site to find out more.

  • About
    • Our Story
    • The Team
      • Christopher Anissian, APMA®
      • Katelyn Cummings, CFP®
      • Bryan Goss
      • Gina Jacobson, CFP®, CDFA
      • Marina Johnson, CFA
      • John LaBarca, CFA
      • Ellen Logan
      • Maria Malloy, CFP®
      • Sue McGrath
      • Sarah Quist, CFP®
      • Jeffrey Schmidt, CFA
      • Matthew Sheets, CFP®
      • Chris Sizemore, CPWA®, CMFC
      • Stacy Sizemore, IACCP®
      • Madison Steinbrenner, IACCP®
      • Liz Swagerty Olsen
      • Cliff Yount, IACCP®
    • Careers
  • How We Help
    • Financial Planning
      • What is Financial Planning?
    • Investment Management
      • Our Approach to Investing
      • Investment Update
      • Environmental Social Governance
  • Who We Help
    • Employees with Stock Compensation
    • Gen X
    • NIKE Employees
    • Nonprofits
    • People Experiencing Life Transitions
    • Professionals
    • Women Seeking Female Financial Advisors
  • Learn More
    • Blog
    • Events
    • FAQ
    • Contact
  • Client Portal
  • Contact

May 14 2018

Total Return Investing and Income-Focused Investing Compared

One of the biggest questions for people entering retirement is how to generate income from their hard-earned savings. Moving from accumulation to withdrawal mode is an uncomfortable transition for many. Setting aside the emotional and behavioral component, what are the logistics involved in creating your own paycheck? From which accounts should you draw and how does this affect your investment strategy?

Total Returns Income

The belief that income and dividends should provide enough to fund your living expenses without having to touch the principal amount of your portfolio is a popular one. While this is a reasonable point of view, it often results in accepting lower expected return for the same level of risk when compared to a total return strategy.

What do we mean by a total return strategy? Glad you asked!

A total return strategy often involves building a diversified portfolio of equity and fixed income securities (stocks and bonds) and using a combination of income (interest and dividends) AND capital gains (increase in value of the securities in the portfolio) to fund your income needs.

The benefit of a total return strategy is the potential for larger and steadier returns over time, which means you could have more money in the pot over the long-term. It also allows you to maintain a consistent risk profile, so you’re not dramatically altering the portfolio at an inopportune time or incurring excessive trading costs.

We know that focusing on income generation and preservation of principal can provide peace of mind because it creates more tangible limits on the amount you can spend. However, focusing solely on income can lead to unintended risks.

Here are a few pitfalls to consider with an income-only strategy:

  • Miscalculating risk

If your desire for income leads to a chase for yield, this often results in purchasing fixed income instruments with either longer maturities or higher credit risk. Or, maybe you choose high yielding mutual funds that hold risky underlying securities, charging higher fees. It might not sound intuitive, but you are often better off from a risk/return perspective by owning equities and lower risk fixed income instruments than chasing higher yielding securities.

  • Concentrating equity holdings

Another pitfall of chasing income is holding large positions in a few stocks that pay high dividends. The number of high dividend paying stocks is fairly limited, which means you would need to own large positions in order to generate a decent amount of income. When a few stocks make up a large percentage of your portfolio, you may not enjoy equity market gains if one or more of the stock’s value falls.

  • Investing in non-traditional asset classes

For sophisticated investors, diversifying beyond traditional asset classes may be worthwhile. However, if you are an average investor, you should avoid taking on risks you don’t understand by investing in funds that offer high dividend yields solely for the purpose of achieving an income goal. These funds often carry unique risks that are generally not appropriate for most investors.

The interest rate environment in recent years has caused many investors to participate in the chase for yield as a means of funding retirement. Most don’t realize that this chase creates additional risk at a time when most people intend to be conservative in their investment strategy. While it may feel right to plan your retirement around the income generated by your portfolio, the expected return for a given level of risk is likely to be higher by building a diversified portfolio around a total return strategy.

Written by Marina Johnson · Categorized: FINANCIAL PLANNING, INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT, INVESTMENTS, RETIREMENT PLANNING · Tagged: TOTAL RETURN INVESTING

Sign up for the Vision Capital Newsletter

More Posts

Video: Reminders during Heightened Market Volatility

Smart Money Moves for Moms at Every Stage

Gina Jacobson Makes Second Appearance on “Wait. Hold Up… What?” Podcast

Post Categories

  • 401K
  • 529 PLAN
  • CHARITABLE GIVING
  • DIVORCE
  • ECONOMY
  • ELLEVATE NETWORK
  • ESTATE PLANNING
  • FIDUCIARY
  • FINANCIAL ADVISOR
  • FINANCIAL PLANNING
  • HEALTH INSURANCE
  • HOME OWNERSHIP
  • INSURANCE
  • INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT
  • INVESTMENTS
  • MEDICARE
  • NIKE
  • OREGON
  • OREGON ECONOMY
  • PARENTING
  • PERSONAL FINANCE
  • REAL ESTATE INVESTING
  • RETIREMENT PLANNING
  • SOCIAL SECURITY
  • TAX PLANNING
  • UNCATEGORIZED
  • WOMEN

Certifications and Associations

Certified Women Owned Business
Certified
Private Wealth Advisor
Certified Financial Planner
CFA Institute
Certified Divorce Financial Analyst
Financial Planning Association Member
  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • 4380 S. Macadam Avenue, Suite 350 Portland, OR 97239
  • (800) 707-5335
  • Directions
    • About
    • Individuals
    • Institutions
    • Resources
    • Contact

    © 2025 Vision Capital Management, Inc. | Privacy Policy | ADV Brochure | ADV Supplement | Form CRS